Navigation
  • Home

Sugar batteries could be greener, cheaper, and store more energy than lithium-ions… or they could be super pretend vaporware

Tech Reporters: WOW! Sugar batteries have energy densities “an order of magnitude higher than” lithium-ion batteries!! #future #i<3science #reprintingthepressrelease


Louie: Yeah, and sugar batteries have voltages an order of magnitude lower than real batteries. It’s a linear trade-off. I can engineer batteries all day that have super-performance along one axis. Why are we talking about this?? #lol #fakeovation


Guess I need to stop reading sci-fluff garbage rags like “Nature“.

Author Description

Louie Helm is a Machine Learning Engineer

4 Responses to “Sugar batteries could be greener, cheaper, and store more energy than lithium-ions… or they could be super pretend vaporware”

  1. January 31

    Indiana Bones

    Nanotube batteries. That’s where the future lies.

  2. January 31

    Mali Benvenutti

    hey- if it works for you, why not batteries? #louiethehumanhummingbird

  3. January 31

    Matt Vana

    Isn’t energy density measured in something like volt*amp*hours/cm^3 and thus independent of voltage?

  4. January 31

    Louie Helm

    Theoretical energy density is independent of theoretical voltage. So one has to wonder why they made such a tiny demonstration device. All the values they’re actually measuring are so low and difficult to measure at the scale they’re dealing with. Only the implied values, like energy density, look impressive. It’s like when people make perpetual motion machines and they’re only generating a very tiny amount of power. Why is that?

    I expect it’s the same issue here. That this research is a rounding error from having devices built so small that their implied values are amazing, but once anyone tries to scale them up, they will see that the values were totally wrong. This is a really common theme among every pop-sci breakthrough of the form “New [academic prototype] X has 3775% the performance of [commercially available, real world thing] Y”.